• Home
  • Book Reviews
  • Books
    • Monthly Wrap Up
    • Giveaways
    • Book Hauls
    • Events
  • Discussions
  • New Releases
  • Features
    • Top Ten Tuesday
    • Romance Thursdays
    • Movie Reviews
    • TV Series Reviews
    • Waiting on Wednesday
  • #LoveOzYA
    • OZYA Interviews
    • OZYA Reviews
  • About
  • Contact
Angel ReadsAngel Reads
  • Home
  • Book Reviews
  • Books
    • Monthly Wrap Up
    • Giveaways
    • Book Hauls
    • Events
  • Discussions
  • New Releases
  • Features
    • Top Ten Tuesday
    • Romance Thursdays
    • Movie Reviews
    • TV Series Reviews
    • Waiting on Wednesday
  • #LoveOzYA
    • OZYA Interviews
    • OZYA Reviews
  • About
  • Contact

Book Review: Trial by Fire by Josephine Angelini

Book Review: Trial by Fire by Josephine Angelini

August 23, 2016 Posted by angelreads Book Reviews 1 Comment

26064760-2Trial by Fire by Josephine Angelini

Pages: 373
Publish date: 2015
Publisher: Macmillan’s Children Books
ISBN: 9781509809875
Purchase: Book Depository – Amazon UK – Amazon US – Amazon AU – Dymocks 

This world is trying to kill Lily Proctor. Her life-threatening allergies keep her from enjoying experiences that others in her hometown of Salem take for granted, which is why she is determined to enjoy her first high school party with her best friend and longtime crush, Tristan. But after a humiliating incident in front of half her graduating class, Lily wishes she could just disappear.

Suddenly, Lily is in a different Salem—one overrun with horrifying creatures and ruled by powerful women called Crucibles. Strongest and cruelest of them all is Lillian . . . Lily’s other self in this alternate universe.

What makes Lily weak at home is what makes her extraordinary in New Salem. In this confusing world, Lily is torn between responsibilities she can’t hope to shoulder alone and a love she never expected.

Trial by Fire:

I received a copy of Trial by Fire by Josephine Angelini from Macmillan’s Children Books in exchange for an honest review, this has in no way influenced my thoughts and feelings about the book.

I honestly don’t know why it took me so long to pick this book up, just by the synopsis I was hooked. It has everything that I enjoy in novels; fantasy, romance, and witches and while it may not be my favourite novel out there, I can say that I loved it and cannot wait to read more.

Trial by Fire follows protagonist Lily Proctor, whose life-threatening allergies keep her from enjoying life so when a high school party comes along she wants to enjoy it with her best friend and long-time crush; but everything doesn’t go to plan. Unexpectedly, Lily is now in a different Salem. A Salem that is full of magic, horrifying creatures and ruled by Lily’s other self in this alternative universe.  

I found at first that Lily was a hard protagonist to get along with, I guess it’s her naivety that stood out; it was just the simplest of things that she couldn’t understand. However, as the novel went on Lily grew immensely and I loved her by the end.

Trial by Fire Quote 1

I loved the dynamic between Lily and the other characters that she meets along the way. They just have this bond about them, that alone kept me wanting to read on. Rowan, Tristan and Caleb are just brilliant, and when all four are brought together, things are bound to happen.  They all have different personalities, but they just all seem to work.

The characterisation of all the main characters was fantastic and each seemed to grow as the novel went on. We would find something about them, that even the character themselves didn’t know. They were so well thought and fleshed out.

I adored the world of Trial by Fire, it was seriously mysterious and awesome. I was intrigued by the get go and I wanted to know more and more as the story went on. The world was so different to other fantasy worlds and I loved it. I also liked the world building of Angelini – she didn’t throw everything at us at once, but she also didn’t leave us hanging. It was a perfect balance.

The dialogue and writing style of Trial by Fire was also epic. Easy to read, flowed perfectly, funny and meaningful at the same time. There were quite a few moments that I had to hold a laugh in so I wouldn’t wake up the whole house.

Now to the romance. Do you know how hard it is to find a fantasy series without a love triangle? – hard, very hard. And when I started the book I thought that was the way it was going to go, but it didn’t and that is a big tick in my books.

Trial by Fire Quote 2

Rowan was so swoon worthy, he just demeaned the attention of the reader whenever he was in a scene. In saying that he was also pretty cranky and something that she cracked me up. I love the tension between Rowan and Lily, it was so intense, much like the book. However, I accidentally read the synopsis for the third book…

However, there is one major thing about Trial by Fire that killed me. The cliff-hanger, and no it wasn’t something small, it was big – like catastrophic. And I am trying to hold off reading the second book, until the release day for the third book is closer.

Overall, Trial by Fire is a captivating read that grabbed my attention from the get go. The world building is fantastic, well fleshed out characters that are fascinating, a world that is immersing and dialogue that is spot on. I am so looking forward to reading more.

Rating

Trial by Fire was my type of book, but how did you enjoy it? Have you read it? Have you read anything else by Josephine Angelini? Are you looking forward to the final book in this series. 

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

1 Comment
Share

1 Comment

Leave your reply.
  • Nick
    · Reply

    August 24, 2016 at 2:23 AM

    I listened to this book as an audiobook and I really enjoyed it too. I did read spoilers about the subsequent books and decided not to pick them up though. It had a really cool concept for sure, pretty unique for YA fantasy. I hope you love the rest of the books too!
    Great review, Angel!

    Loading...

Leave a Reply

Your email is safe with us.
Cancel Reply

Recent Posts

  • Books Covers With Typography That I Love | TTT
  • New To Me Authors I Loved in 2025
  • My Favourite Reads of 2025
  • Most Anticipated Books Releasing in the First Half of 2026
  • Slow but an Okay August | Monthly Wrap Up

Subscribe to Angel Reads

Enter your email address to subscribe to Angel Reads and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Bookstagram

angelreads

book blogger 💻| romance books 💜| bookseller 📖
💌 angel@angelreads.com
📚15/150

I have a love-hate relationship with this series. I have a love-hate relationship with this series. But I ended up really enjoying this one. It’s best friends to fake dating to-lovers. It’s always been you, bad-boy/good-girl, and I loved that. While Save Your Breath has quite a few tropes, it really leads itself to it, and it works. 

Aleks and Mia have known each other for years now. Since they were teenagers, that angst has been building up this whole time. And you can tell right from the get-go, it’s fantastic. I even wanted more of it, because I love pain. When Aleks went to live with Mia’s family as a teenager, sparks flew, but for many reasons, they both put their feelings aside. And well, now they are not only going to be fake-dating, but they might as well be engaged, too. 

I really enjoyed seeing how both Aleks and Mia both tried to hide how they were feeling throughout the whole ‘fake-dating’ situation, but anyone could see it. They know each other as no one else does. Aleks has a lot going on, and while I do think this was brushed over a little too much, Mia is his centre. Mia is a massive music star and is a female in the industry, so yeah, people don’t respect her. Obvsiouly because why couldn’t a female star be badass and write about the things that she has gone through? Aleks and Mia get each other, and that is very clear from the start; they are both just trying to squash everything. We get to see them slowly start to show how they feel, and well, one night it all explodes. 

Overall, I enjoyed this one a lot; it’s not my favourite of the series, but I had a great time reading it. I liked Aleks and Mia a lot as characeters and while I think the mental health aspect could have been explored a whole lot more, I can see why it wasn’t. The romance was slow and spicy, the angst was great, and the payoff for these two was what they needed. 

Tropes
🏒Sports/Hockey Romance
🎤Fake Dating/Engagement
🏒Childhood Friends to Lovers
🎤Forced Proximity
🏒Athlete x Pop Star 
🎤Angsty Slow Burn 

Content Warnings
Mental Health Struggles 
Suicide Intention 
Family Deaths 
Alcohol Consumption
Violence on Ice

🏷️ 
#romancebooks #bookstagram  #angelreads #spicybooks #bookreview
Well February wasn’t the best reading month. I onl Well February wasn’t the best reading month. I only ended up reading 3 books in. 3 pretty fun books but one of my slowest readings months in a while. 

And I’m going to be honest here it’s because I’ve been constantly reading Heated Rivalry fanfics. 🤷‍♀️ I’m having the best time though. 

How was your reading in February? Any 5  star reads? 

🏷️ 
#romancebooks #bookstagram  #angelreads #spicybooks #februarywrapup
January was a really solid reading month. I read s January was a really solid reading month. I read some books that had been on my tbr for some time, reread a few things that peaked my interest. I also started a few new series. And just had a good time!

I just had a really good start to the year. While February is a little slow so far I’m looking forward to what I can pick up.

What did you read in January? Any 5-star reads? Let’s chat! 

🏷️ 
#romancebooks #bookstagram  #angelreads #spicybooks #januarywrapup
Can you believe that it’s already February? I know Can you believe that it’s already February? I know I can’t. But that means it’s a new month with more releases coming out! And that makes me excited. Some fantastic titles releasing this month and I cannot wait to read them. 📚

A couple of these are on my TBR already and some have just caught my eye and that makes me super excited to pick them up. 🖤

What are you looking forward to reading this month? Let’s chat! ✨

🏷️ 
#romancebooks #bookstagram  #angelreads #spicybooks #Februaryreleases2026
Follow on Instagram

GoodReads

2026 Reading Challenge

2026 Reading Challenge
Angel - Angel Reads has read 0 books toward her goal of 150 books.
hide
0 of 150 (0%)
view books

Contact Us

Send us an email and I'll get back to you, asap.

Send Message

© 2013 - 2026 · Angel Reads · Disclaimer

Prev Next
%d